Filling seven volumes, the French novelist Marcel Proust’s In Search of Lost Time is widely considered one of the great masterpieces of the 20th century. Several of the work’s characters, including one of the most important, Charles Swann, are Jews, and Proust himself was the baptized son of a Catholic father and Jewish mother. According to one of his biographers, notes Joseph Epstein, he “never thought himself a Jew, though he did not protest being called one—and yet this did not, of course, stop others from considering him a perfect example of the Jews of that day.”
Epstein asks, “to what extent did Marcel Proust’s Jewishness contribute to the making of In Search of Lost Time?”
Proust, while theologically uninterested in Judaism, thought Jewishly. By thinking Jewishly, I mean that in [his writing he] showed an essentially Jewish point of view—a slightly self-deprecating, sometimes comic, yet ultimately serious view of the world. In our time, not all Jewish writers had it. Saul Bellow did; Norman Mailer, who in his penchant for violence and hipness wasn’t especially keen on being a Jew, didn’t; Bernard Malamud did; Philip Roth, who viewed the world through a rather coarse Freudianism and callow liberal politics, also didn’t; among poets, Karl Shapiro had it, while Allen Ginsberg distinctly did not, as Gregory Corso or Lawrence Ferlinghetti could as easily have written “Howl.”
In the end, there is something ineluctably Jewish about his novel. Proust’s maternal family was well established among French Jews, to the point of having its members buried in the Jewish section of the Père Lachaise Cemetery in Paris. At his mother’s death in 1905, Proust sought a Jewish burial for her, with a rabbi in attendance to say the mourner’s kaddish.
The author of this In Search of Lost Time is someone who calibrated every element of status in French society and did so with just that modicum of insecurity that a less than altogether secure status itself makes possible. . . . In Search of Lost Time could have been written only by a Jew.
More about: Jewish literature, Jews in literature, Marcel Proust