Despite all the signs of a rising tide of anti-Semitism, observes Meir Soloveichik, the United States remains a uniquely philo-Semitic country, and one whose citizens overwhelmingly sympathize with Israel. “Before America,” Soloveichik adds, “there was Amsterdam.”
It was in Amsterdam that the Jews of Europe—expelled from England and burned alive in the autos-da-fé of Spain and Portugal—first found a beacon of freedom in the 1600s. As the historian Steven Nadler notes, the fact that this occurred is not happenstance; it “goes right to the heart of Dutch identity in the 17th century, particularly as this evolved through the struggle for independence from Spain and the political, social, and artistic forces unleashed by that crusade. . . . The Dutch found in Hebrew Scripture a rich source of models for both martial and civic virtues: courage, temperance, fortitude, wisdom, and justice.”
But it was not in the Netherlands that Jews found full equality; that would come only in the country that would place human equality at the core of its creed and consider itself covenantal in seeking to further this vision.
It is both ironic and frightening that the city that once led the way in tolerating Jews has now seen one of the 21st century’s severest outbreaks of anti-Semitic violence. Soloveichik concludes:
What happened in Amsterdam is, of course, a warning for America, for it is, alas, not difficult to imagine a similar mob made manifest on an Ivy League college quad or on the streets of Los Angeles or New York. Nevertheless, . . . one truth is quite clear. The commonality between America and Israel—and the bond built upon it—endures. And surely, whatever one’s views on the many policy questions facing this country in this season of Thanksgiving, that is a reason for gratitude.
More about: American Jewish History, Anti-Semitism, Dutch Jewry, Philo-Semitism