Ethical Investing Still Has Israel in Its Sights

Nov. 23 2022

Last year, Morningstar—a leading provider of financial services—came under fire because its subsidiary, a company called Sustainalytics, had been systematically giving low “environmental, social, and governance” (ESG) ratings to companies that do business with Israel. Investors have come to rely on ESG ratings as a way of reassuring themselves and their clients that their money isn’t being used unethically. As a result, Morningstar announced last month that it had taken a series of steps to avoid further hostility toward the Jewish state. In an in-depth analysis, Richard Goldberg argues that there is reason to believe the underlying problems have not disappeared. In fact, Goldberg suggests, Sustainalytics seems to be acting in a way that supports the campaign to boycott, divest from, and sanction the Jewish state (BDS).

A core premise of the BDS campaign has permeated Morningstar Sustainalytics’ ESG risk assumptions: east Jerusalem, the entirety of the West Bank, Gaza, and the Golan Heights are deemed Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT) where Israel is [supposedly] committing systemic human-rights violations against Palestinians, and all companies operating in these areas are—based simply on their location—at risk of contributing to human-rights abuses. This presumption of human-rights risk triggers the company’s incident team to investigate companies operating in or around these territories for controversy ratings.

In a document responding to questions on why an Israeli telecommunications company operating in the West Bank received a “Category 3 Significant controversy” rating, Sustainalytics wrote, “Our perspective is that the current operations in the Occupied Territories create an unmanageable human-rights risk for the company.” That presumption upends the Oslo Accords, however, which allowed for an Israeli presence in various parts of the West Bank and which envisioned Israel retaining portions of the West Bank. Notably, the presumption that any Israeli presence beyond Israel’s 1967 border is a human-rights violation is one of the same presumptions used by the BDS campaign.

This approach leads to the infliction of harm on Israeli and Israel-connected companies. Israeli banks, for example, receive a Category 3 Significant controversy rating simply for providing services to Jews living in parts of Jerusalem—the capital of the Jewish state and home to the Western Wall — or the disputed West Bank.

Read more at FDD

More about: BDS, ESG, Finance, Morningstar

Mahmoud Abbas Condemns Hamas While It’s Down

April 25 2025

Addressing a recent meeting of the Palestine Liberation Organization’s Central Committee, Mahmoud Abbas criticized Hamas more sharply than he has previously (at least in public), calling them “sons of dogs.” The eighty-nine-year-old Palestinian Authority president urged the terrorist group to “stop the war of extermination in Gaza” and “hand over the American hostages.” The editors of the New York Sun comment:

Mr. Abbas has long been at odds with Hamas, which violently ousted his Fatah party from Gaza in 2007. The tone of today’s outburst, though, is new. Comparing rivals to canines, which Arabs consider dirty, is startling. Its motivation, though, was unrelated to the plight of the 59 remaining hostages, including 23 living ones. Instead, it was an attempt to use an opportune moment for reviving Abbas’s receding clout.

[W]hile Hamas’s popularity among Palestinians soared after its orgy of killing on October 7, 2023, it is now sinking. The terrorists are hoarding Gaza aid caches that Israel declines to replenish. As the war drags on, anti-Hamas protests rage across the Strip. Polls show that Hamas’s previously elevated support among West Bank Arabs is also down. Striking the iron while it’s hot, Abbas apparently longs to retake center stage. Can he?

Diminishing support for Hamas is yet to match the contempt Arabs feel toward Abbas himself. Hamas considers him irrelevant for what it calls “the resistance.”

[Meanwhile], Abbas is yet to condemn Hamas’s October 7 massacre. His recent announcement of ending alms for terror is a ruse.

Abbas, it’s worth noting, hasn’t saved all his epithets for Hamas. He also twice said of the Americans, “may their fathers be cursed.” Of course, after a long career of anti-Semitic incitement, Abbas can’t be expected to have a moral awakening. Nor is there much incentive for him to fake one. But, like the protests in Gaza, Abbas’s recent diatribe is a sign that Hamas is perceived as weak and that its stock is sinking.

Read more at New York Sun

More about: Hamas, Mahmoud Abbas, Palestinian Authority