Solving Israel’s Qatar Dilemma https://mosaicmagazine.com/picks/israel-zionism/2023/12/solving-israels-qatar-dilemma/

December 12, 2023 | Yoel Guzansky and Ilan Zalayat
About the author:

Yoel Guzansky and Ilan Zalayat explain why Jerusalem has been willing to deal with Hamas’s sponsors in Doha until now:

Israel’s Qatari dilemma is thus: although the connection between Qatar and Hamas harms Israeli interests, at the same time, thanks to its ties with the organization, Qatar has served, and continues to serve, other Israeli interests.

The Qatari transfer of money to Hamas was welcomed by Israel, which was beguiled by the false quiet that it bought. . . . Israel hoped that these funds would encourage Hamas to maintain the security calm. . . . The Qatari envoy to Gaza, Mohammed al-Emadi, was seen by Israel as a convenient channel for relaying messages to Hamas.

Now that this approach appears to have failed, what should Israel do?

Given that the most effective way to apply pressure on Qatar is through the United States, Israel should appeal to the Biden administration to pressure the Qatari regime to change its policy. For example, Israel should ensure, in part by appealing to Washington, that the presence of Hamas leaders in Qatar becomes a burden for Doha. However, since Washington sees Qatar as an asset, Israel should lower its expectations—even when it comes to the American promise that it has agreed with Doha that the Qataris will “reexamine” their ties with Hamas after the war.

Consequently, any change in Israeli policy toward Qatar—for example, by trying to assassinate senior Hamas figures who have been given refuge in Qatar—could encounter stiff U.S. opposition, especially in the short term.

Far better than Doha’s expulsion of Hamas’s seniormost leaders, who will inevitably find refuge elsewhere, and better even than their assassination by the Mossad, would be if Qatar arrests them and hands them over to the U.S., sending a clear message that the game is up for the terrorist group.

Read more on Institute for National Security Studies: https://www.inss.org.il/publication/qatar-gaza/