Haredim and the IDF: Learning a Lesson from the Tsars

June 20 2024

In Israeli domestic politics, issues surrounding the Haredim and their relationship with the state are again at the forefront. Recent legislation regarding the enlistment of yeshiva students—a longstanding point of contention that, given the current demands the war is placing on reservists, has become a greater than ever source of resentment—came close to toppling the government last week. Then followed a dust-up in the Knesset concerning the appointment of local rabbis, the details of which are too arcane to explain here, which also highlighted the tensions between Haredim and non-Haredim.

Brian Horowitz suggests looking to tsarist Russia’s nine decades of efforts to conscript Jews to think about solutions to the problem of haredi enlistment. During the reign of Tsar Nicholas I (1825–1855), Russian Jews had good reason to see army service as cruel, dangerous, and likely to destroy conscripts’ connection to Judaism. Their attempts to resist conscription ended up having terrible effects on Jewish communal life. Yet the Russian government had more success when it adopted more liberal policies:

In the case of haredi conscription in Israel, it might be possible to put in shorter service terms for members who receive secular education and training for jobs outside yeshiva study halls. However, if haredi recruitment is imposed like in Nicholas’s time with the power of selection in the hands of the rabbinic elite, a similar situation will likely arise in which some boys will go to the military because they lack prowess as scholars, while others will be victims of corruption. This picture will not be pretty.

Some people will continue to strive to change haredi attitudes toward the state. I don’t think that we should expect change in the short run. . . . Today’s stratification of military service in Israel cannot stand, but the proposals for haredi service must include incentives as well as demands.

While Horowitz looks at the problem as an outsider, it’s worth noting that the haredi journalist (and yeshiva student) Moshe Shafer takes a similar approach, arguing that Israeli Haredim have based their approach to the Israeli government on strategies of premodern Jewish representatives “pleading before the classic Polish aristocrat.” He believes it’s time for a change, calling on his fellow Haredim, who have already accepted the rights of citizenship, to accept the responsibilities as well.

Read more at Fathom

More about: Haredim, IDF, Israeli society, Jews in the military, Russian Jewry

The Democratic Party Is Losing Its Grip on Jews

Since the 1930s, Jews have been one of America’s most solidly Democratic ethnic groups. Although, true to form, a majority again voted for Kamala Harris, something clearly has shifted. John Podhoretz writes:

Over the course of the past thirteen months, Jews in America have been harassed, threatened, seen their ancestral homeland derided as a settler-colonial genocidal state. They have seen Jewish kids mistreated on college campuses. And they have seen the Biden administration kowtow to Muslim populations hostile to Jews and the Jewish state in Michigan. They have heard the criticisms of Israel’s efforts to defend itself, and have noted the silence from the administration when it came to anti-Semitic assaults and the refusal of college presidents to condemn the treatment of Jews and Jewish topics under their ambit.

And Jews have acted.

The initial evidence from last night’s election is that there has been a significant shift in the Jewish vote from previous elections, a delta of anywhere from 10 to 40 percent overall.

Read more at Commentary

More about: 2024 Election, American Jewry, Anti-Semitism, Democrats, U.S. Politics