Every few hours for the past several days, there has been some new morsel of news about the ceasefire negotiations, their chances of success, and the remaining bones of contention. Among them it seems is Israel’s continued control of the Philadelphi Corridor, the border strip between Gaza and Egypt, which since 2007 has been the main conduit of arms to Hamas. Ariel Kahana explains that withdrawing from the corridor, under which the IDF has located dozens of smuggling tunnels, before Hamas is defeated would be tantamount to “reviving” the terrorist group.
David M. Weinberg, meanwhile, examines the risks of a ceasefire even if it doesn’t involve such major concessions—and the cruel dilemma Israel faces:
According to government sources, the deal currently under discussion between Israel and Hamas would see between 500 and 1,000 Palestinian terrorists, 100 of them considered “heavy” terrorists (i.e., bloodthirsty butchers), released from Israeli jails in exchange for 22 live Israeli hostages, mainly women and other civilians, alongside the bodies of another dozen deceased hostages.
Some Israelis will argue that the IDF can be sent back continuously to crush Hamas in Gaza after the deal is done (although manifestly, this will not be possible given inevitable diplomatic restraints).
The released terrorists assuredly will strike again, with God-only-knows how many Israeli casualties in the future. . . . I know this to be a fact because this has been the case with every previous terrorist release. Israel repeatedly has erred by letting terrorists loose to murder more Israelis. And each time, in advance of every deal, the Israeli security establishment . . . assured Israeli politicians and the public that it “would know how to manage the situation,” i.e., how to track the terrorists and crush any nascent return to terrorist activity without too much harm done.
But this has never proved to be true. Every deal involving the release of terrorists has led to much bloodshed, planned and carried out by these released terrorists.
More about: Gaza War 2023, Israeli Security, Palestinian terror