Since Britain’s current government took office, it has dropped its objections to the International Criminal Court’s attempt to issue an arrest warrant for Prime Minister Netanyahu; restored funding to UNRWA, despite many of its employees being outed as terrorists; and restricted arms exports to Israel. “In none of these cases,” writes Tom Harris, “can we see any similarity with what previous Labor governments would have done.”
Usually, the Labor turn against Israel is understood in the context of the party’s former leader, the anti-Semitic radical leftist Jeremy Corbyn. But Harris believes the shift started in 2010, under Corbyn’s far more moderate Jewish predecessor, Ed Miliband.
In his first conference speech as [party] leader, Miliband generously announced that Israel had the right to exist—a peculiar statement, since he felt no compunction to say the same thing about any other nation. But Miliband’s equivocation on Israel, a product of his desire to flirt with the left that had given him the edge over his older brother in the leadership contest, only presaged what was yet to come.
Harris looks at the reasons for the shift, which has persisted even after Corbyn’s ouster by the current prime minister, Keir Starmer, who has made a point of repairing relations with British Jews:
[T]he case for concluding that these [anti-Israel] policies have been pursued specifically in order to assuage Muslim opinion in the UK is convincing, if not overwhelming. . . . In campaigners’ experience, will there ever be a point, short of declaring that Israel should abolish itself in favor of a Greater Palestine, that more extreme Muslim opinion is satisfied? How far must the government go along the path it has chosen before it starts to win back that lost support in northern and midlands seats?
The answer, of course, is that extremists tend to demand extreme things. Those who march each week for Palestine and who voted for pro-Gaza candidates at the general election will never, ever be satisfied with a government that does anything other than express complete opposition to Israel.
By reasserting its principled support for Israel and by helping its efforts to remove Hamas as a player in Gaza, the government would be honoring its own liberal principles. It would also be sending an important signal to the pro-Palestine movement and the Islamists and terrorist apologists who dwell in its shadow: our principles of tolerance are not for sale, however many votes you think you can deprive us of.
More about: Anglo-Jewry, Anti-Semitism, Ed Miliband, Jeremy Corbyn, Keir Starmer, Labor Party (UK)