In 2022, a Jewish couple in Tennessee sued the Holston United Methodist Home for Children for refusing to enroll them in its certification program for parents planning to adopt children—on the grounds that it only offers its services to fellow Christians. The suit aims to challenge a 2020 state law that permits denominational adoption agencies to discriminate on religious grounds. Avi Shafran, an Orthodox rabbi and activist, explains why he believes the law should be upheld:
I want religious adoption agencies to be able to choose to limit their services to those whose lives are in consonance with the agencies’ missions. There are already established religious “ministerial” and “conscience” exceptions to many anti-discrimination statutes. It seems reasonable to me that religious adoption agencies, too, should be able to maintain their religious values.
This freedom is especially compelling for Jewish adoption agencies, because, while Judaism may be a faith, being a Jew is an identity. . . . And so, believing Jews consider it incumbent upon them to do all they can to ensure that all of their relatives, no matter how distant, are aware of their identity as part of the Jewish people. And thus, for us, it is vitally important for a religious Jewish adoption agency to be able to place Jewish children with Jewish families, who will provide an environment conducive to the adoptees’ understanding of their identity.
Read more at Religion News Service
More about: Adoption, American Jewry, Freedom of Religion