With everything happening in the Middle East, it was easy to lose sight of a minor but significant political story: Rashida Tlaib, an obsessively anti-Israel Michigan congresswoman, lambasted her state’s Jewish attorney general, Dana Nessel, leading Nessel’s defenders to accuse Tlaib of thinly veiled anti-Semitism. The editors of the Free Press take a closer look:
The trouble began for Attorney General Dana Nessel—[a Jewish] progressive lesbian—when she had the gall to do her job: namely, to prosecute criminals. The criminals in question were mainly anti-Israel protesters at the University of Michigan who resisted arrest and refused to leave an encampment on the Ann Arbor campus.
Unlike so many other state attorneys general, who have lacked the political will to indict politically inconvenient criminals, Nessel did. Two of the protesters were prosecuted for trespassing, another seven were charged with trespassing and resisting arrest, and two more pro-Israel demonstrators were prosecuted for separate incidents involving a counterprotest at last spring’s encampment.
Tlaib’s complaint about “possible biases” in Nessel’s office was understood by many as implying that Nessel was acting out of especially Jewish bias. The suggestion that there was an anti-Semitic dimension to Tlaib’s comment itself provoked outrage:
Check out any of your favorite progressive publications—the Intercept, the New Republic, Zeteo—and the story is the inverse of reality. They argue that Nessel is the bigot for smearing Tlaib with the stain of anti-Semitism. It becomes Nessel who has defamed Tlaib—and who must be held to account. This is extraordinary considering that Nessel appointed the first Arab American state solicitor general in American history, Fadwa Hammoud.
This kind of gaslighting has become an unfortunate pattern for progressives since October 7. A couple of examples: after a horrific pogrom where Jewish Israeli parents were murdered in front of their children, it was Israel that was the aggressor. Israel’s defensive war, according to this warped logic, is a genocide. Meanwhile Hamas, the perpetrators of the genocidal act, are the noble resistance.
More about: Anti-Semitism, Rashida Tlaib, U.S. Politics