Hard as it may be to believe, it has barely been six weeks since the U.S. elections. Jay Lefkowitz examines the preferences of Jewish voters, and the role Israel plays in national politics:
Today, Israel is clearly a partisan, and divisive, issue. Shockingly, however, it is not an especially decisive issue for most Jewish voters. And the reason is that beyond the 10 to 15 percent of American Jews who are either ultra- or Modern Orthodox, Israel is far from the top of most Jewish voters’ list of priorities—trailing abortion, climate change, immigration, inflation, and healthcare, according to a recent study published by the Jewish Democratic Council of America.
While the data from the recent election show a move to the right by Jewish voters, it was not nearly as significant a shift as many Republicans had hoped for, given the prevailing political winds post-October 7. In fact, the Trump-ward shift was only partly due to Jewish perspectives on the pro-Israel positions of the two leading candidates. An even bigger factor was that the fastest growing segment of the Jewish community, the ultra-Orthodox Jews (or Haredim), voted overwhelmingly for Trump. And while their votes were certainly influenced by the perception that Democrats are more hostile than Republicans to Israel and even complicit in the rise of anti-Semitism, especially on college campuses, the haredi vote for Trump was also heavily influenced by social issues.
Nor has October 7 done much to shake up the political landscape in the Jewish community. . . . [Even] if the rise of anti-Semitism across the United States has reminded Jews of their identity, outside of the small number of observant Zionist communities, it has yet to have had much impact on Jewish voting patterns.
For Jews to have the greatest political clout, they will have to become swing voters whom either party believes it can win over. Only the Modern Orthodox, in Lefkowitz’s analysis, fit that criterion. He concludes:
If secular Jews are safely ensconced in the Democratic party, and haredi Jews (at least in presidential elections) are equally committed to the Republican party, Israel will surely find itself much more isolated politically in the United States in the coming decade.
More about: 2024 Election, American Jewry, U.S. Politics