On the first night of Passover, Cody Balmer smashed a window at the home of Pennsylvania’s Governor Josh Shapiro—where he and his family were hosting a seder—and tossed Molotov cocktails inside. Balmer told police that he was motivated by what Shapiro “plans to do the Palestinian people.” Neil Zuckerman comments:
In the hours before this violent act, Governor Josh Shapiro sat at his family’s Passover seder table and read the ancient words of the Haggadah: “In every generation, there are those who rise up to destroy us.” . . . But those same words that name the threat also carry the answer: “God delivers us from the hands of our enemies.” In other words, we are still here. We are not scared. And we are not going anywhere.
This incident resonates far beyond Pennsylvania. It reflects a global conflict in which too many still refuse to accept a basic truth: the Jewish people are not going anywhere. We have been connected to the Land of Israel for thousands of years, and the people of Israel are here to stay, in our ancestral homeland. Any vision for peace must begin with that acknowledgment. To those who have marched since October 7—condemning Israel and aligning with Hamas—I would say this: the best way to support the people of Gaza is to help them come to terms with that reality.
Noah Rothman adds:
The suspect appeared to believe that he had meted out a righteous blow for justice, and he seems convinced that the community of pro-Palestinian activists would celebrate his actions and martyrdom.
That’s not an unreasonable bet. It was that incentive structure that convinced Balmer to execute a pro-Palestinian terrorist attack on U.S. soil. What else would you call this event? It is an unexceptional expression of the violent passions that typify anti-Israel activism, whether it takes place in the West Bank, Western Europe’s streets and synagogues, or America’s college campuses.
More about: Anti-Semitism, Anti-Zionism, Haggadah