Recently the White House floated a proposal to provide parents with $5,000 upon the birth of a child. Similar schemes have been tried by European countries hoping to counteract even more severely declining birthrates. Tim Carney explains the possible benefits:
Nearly every year since 2007, Americans have had fewer and fewer babies. The birthrate in the United States has fallen from about 2.1 babies per woman in 2007 to 1.6 in 2023. The working-age population will soon start shrinking, and schools all over America are consolidating and downsizing to adjust to this demographic decline.
Evidence suggests that the most effective way for a national government to boost birthrates is not through targeted measures such as universal daycare or mandated maternity leave, but by providing substantial cash payments to parents for each child they have.
Childbirth brings with it many one-time costs: hospital and doctor bills, a new crib and baby clothes, moving into a bigger apartment, or taking time off work. Also, new parents, being younger, tend to have lower incomes than older parents, so it makes sense to shift some family support closer to birth. [Moreover], a large check soon after birth, separate from tax returns, is more tangible for parents and can be more of an incentive.
Still, countries like Hungary and Singapore that have leaned into baby bonuses and similar policies have seen only limited effects. Carney explains why it seems “cost and affordability” are not the main reasons for declining birthrates, and therefore economic measures can only do so much:
First, consider that the birthrate was much higher in 2008—in the midst of the Great Recession—than it is today or was in 2019, when the economy was stellar. Second, the baby bust is concentrated among millennials and Generation Z, who are not poorer than Generation X or baby boomers were. Third, geographical variations in costs do not seem to predict geographical variations in birthrate.
Read more at Washington Examiner
More about: Birthrate, Fertility, U.S. Politics