Taking as his starting point the Jewish origins of Christianity, Walter Russell Mead speculates about what Christians are to make of the doctrine—undeniable for many believers—that the Jews are God’s chosen people, and then asks why peoplehood, also known as nationalism, should matter at all:
In contemplating Christmas, [Christians] should never forget that the first Christmas was first and foremost a Jewish event. Mary, Joseph, the innkeeper, the shepherds, the baby: they were all Jewish. And as the baby Jesus moved toward adolescence and adulthood, it was Jewish religion, Jewish literature, Jewish culture, and Jewish history that shaped his personality and his mind. . . . New Year’s Day has long been celebrated as the Feast of the Circumcision, the day on which the baby Jesus . . . underwent the traditional rite that, from the time of Abraham, was seen as proclaiming the special relationship between the Jewish people and God. . . .
Why would a universal God who presumably loves all people equally choose one people with whom to have a special relationship? How can we reconcile the claims of this special relationship with God’s commitment to universal justice? . . .
In Europe and many other parts of the world today, many intelligent people look back in horror . . . on the whole bloody history of nationalism. . . They hope to build a transnational or post-national society that rests on universal principles and global institutions more than on the customs and claims of the world’s many peoples.
They’ve got a point. . . . But I don’t think the world is going to learn Esperanto anytime soon. That is, the pull of national and religious identity is too strong to be ignored—and the pull of cosmopolitan civilization and universal institutions is ultimately too weak to call forth the kind of economic and political solidarity that some kind of world government would need. Germans don’t want to pay the bill for early-retiring Greeks in the EU; they have even less solidarity with Uganda and Laos.
Read more at American Interest
More about: Christianity, Christmas, Jewish-Christian relations, Nationalism, Religion & Holidays