While this week’s Torah reading of Emor, like most of the book of Leviticus, is concerned primarily with law and ritual, it includes an odd narrative passage in which a man with an Israelite mother and an Egyptian father gets into a fight with an Israelite, and then “blasphemed the name of the Lord, and cursed.” He is immediately arrested, after which Moses inquires of God about the appropriate punishment. God responds by commanding that “all that heard him lay their hands upon his head, and let all the congregation stone him.”
As Mark Glass points out, the crime committed by the unnamed son of an Israelite mother (whom Glass dubs Ben Shelomit) isn’t so much blasphemy in the usual sense but uttering the ineffable name of God in order to curse another person. Glass examines various anomalies in the story, including the strange biographical detail about the blasphemer’s parentage, and observes:
The onlookers, those who witnessed Ben Shelomit’s fight with a Jew, must lay their hands upon him―in recognition of their guilt, as though he is an offering on their behalf. Because the only reason Ben Shelomit resorted to his act was the onlookers’ failure to help him or break up the fight. The crowd stood around watching―perhaps simply unwilling to intervene, or perhaps with a more vindictive mentality: enjoying an Egyptian being attacked by a Jew for a change.
Had anyone from the crowd stepped in, Ben Shelomit would never have uttered God’s Name and called on Him to strike his opponent. Thus, his sin is―in part―their blame. Ben Shelomit must suffer the ultimate consequence of his actions, but the onlookers must accept their role in his sin. Indeed, the entire people must lay their hands on him and take part in his execution to reinforce their collective responsibility for one another.
More about: Hebrew Bible, Leviticus