Having recently attended services at two churches, one belonging to the Episcopal Church, long one of the most important American denominations, and the other to a “more conservative” offshoot, Stephen Cranney writes:
At the former, known for its grand architecture and progressive stance on contemporary social issues, the congregation was dignified yet notably older. At the second location, a congregation buzzed with energy. Young families filled the pews, cutting-edge media accompanied a crisp, not missing-a-beat homily from a relatively young preacher.
The statistics, Cranney notes, back up his observation: attendance at mainstream Episcopalian churches has dropped dramatically over the past ten years, while the conservative offshoot, the Anglican Church of North America, has grown steadily. And the same is true for other denominations as well:
If liberalization and changing doctrines to align more closely with faddish social sentiment make a religion more popular, we would expect to see these trends reversed. . . . While almost all faiths are struggling in the increasingly secular 21st century, it seems clear that the “liberal” faiths are struggling more than others. The reasons why are complex, and it is impossible fully to address the debate here, but . . . it is likely that churches that exhibit some tension with the background environment, that are distinctive enough for people to see something different in them, are the ones that thrive.
More about: American Religion, Decline of religion