To American Jews, the cheeseburger epitomizes the combination of meat and dairy prohibited by Jewish law, and new advances in technology for producing artificial meat—as Chaim Saiman discussed in Mosaic a few months ago—may put that forbidden combination in reach. Ari Elias-Bachrach looks at both historical precedents and at rabbinic approaches to emerging possibilities:
Attempts at making an imitation cheeseburger for kosher-keeping Jews are nearly as old as the cheeseburger itself. Until now, most efforts have focused on using either faux-meat or faux-dairy made from alternative food sources like soy. . . . The first evidence we have of someone using legumes deliberately to create an imitation dairy product dates to 1899. Almeda Lambert, a Seventh-day Adventist, published a cookbook entitled Guide for Nut Cookery, which includes recipes for “ice cream” made from almonds, peanut milk, and nut cream.
Indeed, while lab-grown meat has generated more headlines, lab-grown dairy is both more immediately feasible and presents fewer halakhic problems:
Recently, a company called Perfect Day has genetically modified a strain of the Trichoderma reesei fungus to produce milk whey proteins. The modified fungi are put in a tank with sugar. They consume the sugar and produce whey protein—one of the two proteins that are present in milk. The final product is identical to the protein produced by cows, but with one key difference for the kosher consumer—no animals are involved in the production. Perfect Day’s protein is currently certified kosher and pareve by the Star-K, despite being the exact same whey protein that is normally derived from milk.
More about: Halakhah, Kashrut, Technology