Considering a recent book on changing attitudes towards aging in 20th-century America, Mira Balberg examines how ancient rabbis understood adult children’s obligations to their parents. Take the Talmud’s description of how Rabbi Tarfon treated his mother:
Every time Rabbi Tarfon’s mother wanted to climb into her bed, he would stoop down to let her up, and every time she would step out of her bed, she would step down onto him. When Rabbi Tarfon was praising himself in the study house, his fellows said, “You have not even reached half the honor that is due one’s parents. Did she ever throw your money into the sea in front of you, while you did not disgrace her?” (Kiddushin 31b)
Nor is this passage exceptional. It seems, Balberg relates, that “one can never properly meet” the obligations imposed by the Fifth Commandment. Yet the rabbis weren’t just interested in displays of devotion, but sensitive to the psychological effects of children having to care for infirm parents:
In the course of its discussion of the obligation to honor one’s parents, the Jerusalem Talmud comments that it is not enough for one to provide for all one’s parents’ physical needs; one must also treat them kindly. [It] tells the story of a son who served his aged father “fattened hens,” that is, sumptuous food, but when the father tried to make conversation during the meal, the son snapped, “Shut up and eat, old man! Dogs are supposed to eat silently.” That son, the Talmud assures us, will end up in hell regardless of what he gave his father.
Read more at Jewish Review of Books
More about: Family, Jewish ethics, Talmud