Last week, Hamas reportedly rejected an Egyptian plan to release hostages and relinquish power in exchange for a permanent ceasefire and Israel’s release of some Palestinian prisoners. Instead, its negotiators are hoping to secure the release of high-profile terrorists like Marwan Barghouti, one of the architects of the second intifada. Avi Issacharoff argues that Hamas’s leaders have fatally misread Israeli intentions, and their hopes of freeing Barghouti and similar figures “lack a firm grip on reality.”
The firm stance of Hamas stems from the belief that [it has] a unique opportunity to extract significant concessions from Israel in terms of the duration of the ceasefire and the identity of Palestinian prisoners to be released in exchange for the Israeli hostages. This attitude has been particularly evident since October 7, marked by assertiveness and a lack of grounding in reality.
True, many Hamas terrorists have survived [the initial Israeli invasion] and continue to launch attacks on IDF forces. While voices in Israel clamor for an immediate prisoner exchange, signs of impatience are evident regarding the realization of the ground operation’s objectives. Yet [Hamas’s top official in Gaza], Yahya Sinwar, and his cohorts have not fully grasped that the Israeli public will not accept anything less than the dismantling of Hamas’s rule in Gaza. Moreover, the Netanyahu government will not endure a long-term ceasefire without significant military achievements. Thus, whether intentionally or not, Hamas’s refusal to enter negotiations on the hostage issue before the cessation of hostilities only serves Israel’s military interests.
The IDF continues to achieve significant military gains daily. Even though it is far from a decisive victory or a collapse of Hamas, more and more of its tunnels are damaged, and more and more terrorists are killed.
More about: Gaza War 2023, Hamas, Israeli Security