The Talmud largely comprises discussion and arguments about Jewish law and scriptural interpretation among various sages whom it presents as familiar characters, without any sort of biographical information, and about whom there are almost no data outside of a few parallel rabbinic texts. Yet scattered throughout its many volumes are countless stories about these individuals. Yonah Lavery-Yisraeli considers the experience of studying of the words of these half-formed characters:
In this cultural moment, many of us are trapped in a seemingly never-ending process of exiling our idols once we discover their faults. Common advice is to remember that our favorites are only human. When people say this, what they mean is to brace for inevitable shortcomings, not to let ourselves fall in love. Such cynicism shrinks our intellectual capacity as surely as it dims our emotional capacity. It is better to remind ourselves that authors are human.
But there is risk in knowing the details because they might distract from a life’s complicated wholeness. For example, one talmudic sage was once a gladiator. I have no doubt at all that killing human beings in a packed arena has an overwhelming impact on who one is and how one experiences the world. But not every opinion of this sage is driven by his former enslavement, and it is dismaying how often his thoughts are reduced to sequelae of his life in the coliseum. . . . The cure is not to avoid the person, or to make them into only one aspect of themselves, but to try to see the person’s face.
More about: Cancel culture, Judaism, Talmud