In A World without Jews: The Nazi Imagination from Persecution to Genocide, Alon Confino goes against the grain of most contemporary Holocaust scholarship, arguing that Nazi anti-Semitism was not very different from the kind that preceded it. David Cesarani writes in his review:
[Alon] Confino boldly rejects the interpretations of Nazism that currently dominate scholarship, asserting that these offer a rather too-comforting explanation. He argues that Nazi anti-Jewish policy cannot be reduced to racism, and certainly not to perverted scientific thinking. Rather, ideas of race and scientific practices were warped to provide the right answers to a predetermined “Jewish question.” Nor did the persecution of the Jews represent a “radicalization” of anti-Semitism or metastasize due to the brutalization of a regime and a people that were in a virtually constant state of imagined or real warfare. On the contrary, the Nazis drew on traditions of Jew-hatred, and the violence they practiced evoked patterns which were rooted in the German past and in Christianity.
Crucially, Confino situates Nazi anti-Semitism within the Christian tradition of anti-Judaism. Although many scholars (and theological apologists) have maintained that National Socialism was anti-religious, Confino states that [its] “aim was not to eradicate Christianity but to eradicate Christianity’s Jewish roots; not to replace Christianity with racism but to blend the two.”
More about: Anti-Semitism, Christianity, History & Ideas, Holocaust, Nazism