Yesterday, 100 Congressional staffers (wearing masks to conceal their identities) staged a walkout to urge their bosses to demand that Israel stop fighting Hamas. On Tuesday, the House of Representatives voted to censure Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib for her various anti-Semitic comments; 22 Democrats voted for the resolution.
These and other developments are evidence of the tensions between a younger, more radical wing of the Democratic party and an older, more pro-Israel establishment. Members of the former wing have argued that senior politicians, including the president himself, risk losing the votes of young progressives unless they cater to their demands. To some observers, it seems likely that White House policy on the current war is shaped by a desire not to alienate this younger, rival wing. But Ruy Teixeira, an analyst of political demographics, argues that there is no need—as the progressives lack real political clout:
I think the progressive left is more of a paper tiger, claiming power and influence way above what they actually have.
Start with the fundamental fact that the progressive or intersectional left, for whom issues from ending fossil fuels to open borders to decriminalizing and decolonizing everything (free Palestine!) are inseparably linked moral commitments, is actually a pretty small slice of voters. . . . So we should ask whether and to what extent their commitments are reflected in the views of the voter groups in whose name they claim to speak.
Probably the most important of these is young voters, lately lionized as Democrats’ best hope—but also perhaps their downfall, if not appropriately catered to. And it is true that young voters generally lean more left than older voters, including in expressing more sympathy for the Palestinians and more opposition to sending weapons to Israel. But that does not mean young voters’ views are therefore in sync with those of the intersectional left and likely to take their cues from activists’ fury at the Biden administration.
More about: Democrats, U.S. Politics, U.S.-Israel relationship