So-called Messianic Judaism is a Christian sect whose members observe some Jewish customs and rituals, and make occasional use of Hebrew. For many of its practitioners, it is a means of proselytizing to Jews. But Richard Cortes—and his initially reluctant wife Alpha—came to Messianic Judaism after a crisis of faith in the Pentecostal Christianity in which he was raised. And that is only the beginning of their unusual story. Asaf Elia-Shalev writes:
By last year, Cortes was leading a thriving Messianic community in a remote mountain town in Arizona [called Show Low]. Drawing from the area’s heavily Mormon and evangelical population, Cortes’s congregation was seen as a successful outpost in the wider Messianic movement.
Yet an uneasy feeling was gnawing at Cortes. Messianism promised that he would find proof of Jesus’ divinity within Jewish texts, but the harder he looked, the less he could see, leaving him in spiritual crisis. He was confused about how to proceed and terrified about the reaction of his wife and congregants to his internal transformation, but he knew he had to make a change.
[In August], Cortes and twenty of his followers converted to Judaism. Dozens of others in his community are considering doing the same.
Their mass conversion is an event with few precedents in Jewish history and a seemingly unlikely outcome for a group of people who live hours away from any Jewish community. The presence in Phoenix of a rabbi with an open mind and unusual point of view and the shifting of Jewish life online because of the pandemic opened doors that might otherwise have been closed.
More about: American Judaism, Conversion